In partnership with
When Howard Pearl stepped into CARS as an interim CEO in 2016 for what was supposed to be a 45-90 day assignment, he discovered something unexpected: a mission-driven organization with incredible potential and a team of talented but constrained employees. Nearly a decade later, he's transformed the company from processing 20,000 vehicles annually with $30M in revenue to handling 150,000 vehicles and over $100M in revenue—all while maintaining less than 2% staff turnover.
CARS CEO Howard Pearl Named Finalist for San Diego Business Journal's 2022 CEO of the Year Award
Here are the key leadership and business lessons every entrepreneur can apply:
1. Lead with Respect, Not Authority
Pearl's entire leadership philosophy centers on one word: respect.
"Leadership has always begun and ended with one word, respect," he explains. "I think you have to start out by giving respect to every individual that works with you or for your organization."
Practical Application:
Treat every team member as capable of "carrying the football on any given day"
Give people permission to make decisions rather than constraining them
Assess strengths and weaknesses, then say "go do" without micromanaging
2. Invest in Your People's Long-Term Success
Despite being a nonprofit with limited salary budgets, CARS retains talent by investing in employee development:
Paying for Master's degrees in Public Administration and MBAs
Sending staff to executive education at Duke, Harvard Business School, and Stanford
Creating "transportable skills" that benefit employees even if they leave
The Counterintuitive Result: Only 3 out of dozens of employees who left ever stayed away. Most returned because they discovered CARS offered something rare—genuine respect and growth opportunities.
3. Transparency Builds Unshakeable Trust
CARS provides 100% financial transparency to their nonprofit partners through a system called NAV, giving partners access to the same financial data the CEO sees.
Business Impact: This transparency has helped CARS secure partnerships with major organizations like St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, which considers them a "top-tier donor" despite the relatively small dollar amounts, because the cost of CARS' money is "insignificant"—no labor-intensive administration required.
4. Adapt Your Communication, Not Your Message
Pearl articulates his vision differently depending on his audience—from board members to auction yard workers—but the core message remains consistent.
"I think you're far more integrous when you can communicate your vision in a way that the individuals you're talking to can take some ownership," he notes.
Key Insight: This isn't about being inauthentic; it's about meeting people where they are. As Pearl puts it: "People do things for their reasons, not yours."
5. Ethics Aren't Negotiable—Even for Small Amounts
In an industry historically plagued by questionable practices, CARS maintains zero tolerance for ethical lapses:
Eliminated incentive programs like gas cards that created perverse motivations
Prosecutes 100% of fraud cases, even misdemeanors, to send a clear message
Operates on a "net" model where they share expenses with nonprofit partners, aligning incentives
The Bottom Line: "There's no such thing as a victimless crime," Pearl emphasizes. Small ethical compromises compound into major problems.
6. Broaden Your Perspective Without Losing Your Center
Pearl's work with nonprofits serving everyone from homeless individuals to sick children fundamentally broadened his worldview while maintaining his core business principles.
"I have allowed room in all of my considerations for things I perhaps wouldn't have considered important in the past," he reflects.
Leadership Lesson: Exposing yourself to the real-world impact of your work—whether it's meeting the end users your nonprofit serves or the customers your product helps—can fundamentally improve your decision-making without compromising business discipline.
7. Technology Should Enhance Human Dignity, Not Replace It
CARS invested heavily in custom software and AI tools, but always with the goal of empowering their team rather than eliminating jobs:
Custom dashboards allow 10 different people to view the same data in ways that match their thinking
AI bots handle routine tasks like appointment confirmations
Real-time access to information helps staff provide better service without stress
8. The Permission to Be Okay
When asked for advice to new CEOs, Pearl's response was refreshingly simple: "Go to the mirror. Look yourself in the eye. Give yourself permission to be okay."
His expanded advice:
You know more than you think you do
Do the work—there are no shortcuts
Don't be afraid to fail; treat failures as education
"You will become what you think about most of the time"
The Unexpected Business Transformation
Perhaps most remarkably, Pearl's experience shows how aligning profit with purpose can actually drive superior business results. By focusing on ethics, transparency, and genuine service, CARS captured market share from competitors, built unshakeable client relationships, and created a sustainable competitive advantage.
"When you're of service, you attract wealth," Pearl observes, citing Amazon's success as an example. "If you're providing a service that makes people's lives better... the rewards follow."
The full conversation reveals much more about Pearl's approach to M&A strategy, handling rapid growth, and building systems that scale. But these seven lessons provide a roadmap for any leader looking to build a business that's both profitable and principled.
What resonates most with you from Howard's approach? Which of these lessons could you implement in your organization this week?
🎙 The BD Podcast
From $0 to $2K in 72 Hours—The "House on Fire" Method
Guest: Prima Jope | Episode 21
When Prima’s mother needed $2,000 for life-saving treatment and she had just 72 hours to find it, everything changed. After nine months of following every online business guru's advice with zero results, desperation forced her to discover a brutal truth about selling that transformed her panic into cash—and eventually built a multiple six-figure business.
This week's episode reveals:
The "House on Fire" method: How to identify the one problem your customer will pay anything to solve RIGHT NOW
Why "nice-to-have" offers get ignored while urgent solutions get bought instantly
The 4 words that accidentally launched a coaching career (and how to find your own)
How to become the only person clients trust with their money—even if they've never heard of you
Prima's story proves that sometimes the best business strategies emerge not from following the rules, but from throwing them out when everything's on the line. Her approach to finding her audience's most urgent, painful problems—their "house on fire"—is a masterclass in positioning that every entrepreneur needs to hear.
Stop selling vitamins to people whose house is on fire. Find the fire, then become the only firefighter they trust.
Discover how to transform your own offerings from ignored "nice-to-haves" into must-have solutions your ideal clients will pay anything to access.
Ready to Lead Like Howard Pearl?
Howard Pearl's transformation from interim CEO to transformational leader—growing CARS from $30M to $100M+ while maintaining less than 2% turnover—demonstrates the power of respect-based leadership, strategic transparency, and mission-driven decision making. Whether you're stepping into your first CEO role, struggling with team retention, or looking to align profit with purpose, the right coach can help you develop the leadership principles that drive both exceptional culture and exceptional results.
Discover your perfect coaching match at CoachFinder.ai
Get matched with top-tier coaches who specialize in:
Respect-based leadership and team empowerment
Organizational transparency and trust-building
Mission-driven strategy and ethical decision making
Communication adaptation across diverse teams
Change management and cultural transformation
Just like Pearl learned to give his team "permission to be okay" while setting the bar high, find the coach who can help you unlock your authentic leadership potential and create lasting impact.
Global payroll complexity? Here’s the playbook.
Managing global payroll shouldn’t mean juggling vendors and compliance risks. Deel, recognized in the Gartner® Market Guide for Multicountry Payroll Solutions, helps finance teams automate payments, standardize reporting, and stay compliant in 100+ countries. Get key insights from industry experts to future-proof your payroll strategy.